Why us vs them ads work
Most purchases are switches. Nobody is buying their first ever soda, sunscreen or pair of headphones — they're deciding whether to replace what they already use. An us vs them ad meets that decision head on: two columns, the familiar option on one side, yours on the other, and the difference visible in about two seconds.
It works for three reasons. Comparison is how people judge value anyway, so the ad does the mental work for them. Contrast sharpens every point: "0 g sugar" is a fact, but "0 g sugar" next to "plenty of sugar" is a reason. And the layout signals confidence — a brand willing to line itself up against the alternative looks like it has nothing to hide.
The style is a close cousin of the problem–solution ad, but more concrete. Instead of describing a pain, it lists specific, checkable differences, which is why it rewards products that genuinely have them.
How to make one, step by step
- Choose the "them" people actually use. Not a strawman — the thing your customer buys today instead of you: regular soda, fast fashion, basic headphones, the office vending machine.
- List every real difference. Ingredients, materials, numbers, how it's made, how long it lasts, cost per use. Keep only the ones you can prove.
- Pick the three or four that matter most. Your reviews and customer questions tell you which. Put the most important difference first.
- Write matched pairs. Each line on your side needs a line on theirs about the same thing — sugar vs sugar, battery vs battery. Unmatched lists read as spin.
- Keep lines to about four words. The format only works at a glance. "Real ginger juice" beats "made with real ginger juice for a natural kick".
- Make the winner obvious. Your side gets the brand colour, the product and the ticks. The other side stays neutral. Don't make it ugly on purpose — make it plain.
- End with a switch-shaped call to action. "Make the swap" frames buying as an upgrade rather than a leap.
Picking a fair "them"
The safest comparison, and usually the most effective, is against a category rather than a competitor: "regular soda", "fast fashion", "basic headphones". Everyone knows what you mean, nobody's logo is involved, and every point can be true of the category in general.
Naming or showing a rival brand is a different matter. Comparative advertising rules vary from country to country, trademark owners do complain, and a specific claim about a specific product has to be accurate for that exact product, today. Unless you've taken legal advice, keep it generic.
Not sure what buyers compare you with? Look at what your competitors lean on in their own ads. BulkAds' competitor ad research reads the Meta Ad Library for your category and shows which angles rivals keep running, so you can see which claims your comparison has to answer.
Ten variations for one test
A comparison ad has four parts you can change: the "them", the points, the visual and the framing. Here's a spread for the Zesty example:
- Zesty vs regular soda, sugar first
- Zesty vs regular soda, ginger first
- Zesty vs the office vending machine
- Zesty vs diet soda, taste and ingredients
- Zesty vs your third coffee of the day
- The winner of 1–5 as a two-photo split instead of a table
- The same, with a price-per-can line added
- The same, rebuilt at 9:16 for Stories
- Checklist style: ticks for Zesty, crosses for the category
- "What's in our can" vs "what's in theirs", ingredients only
Numbers 1–5 are genuinely different ad angles — each "them" speaks to a different buyer with a different reason to switch. Numbers 6–10 are executions of the strongest one. Test the angles first, find the one that sells, then test executions of it. The ad variation calculator shows how quickly these multiply and what testing them would cost, and the hook bank has openers for the primary text.
How to test comparison ads
Run the variations in one ad set: one ad per creative, broad targeting, and enough budget for each ad to spend a couple of times your target cost per purchase before you judge it. Judge on purchases and cost per purchase, not reactions. Comparison ads can attract comments from fans of the other side, which inflate engagement without selling anything.
Pay attention to which "them" wins. If "vs the vending machine" beats "vs regular soda", you've learned who your buyer is — an office worker at 3pm — as well as which ad to scale. That should shape your next batch of every template, not just this one.
Once you have a winning image, run a second, smaller test on the words above it. Keep the creative and change only the primary text: one version restates the comparison, one tells a one-line story of someone switching, one leads with your offer. The image earns the attention, but the copy often decides whether a comparison turns into a purchase.
Common mistakes and the line not to cross
- Unprovable points. "Tastes better" is an opinion, "0 g sugar" is a fact. Comparisons need facts.
- Unfair "them" lines. Making the category sound worse than it is invites replies that say so — publicly, under your ad.
- Too many rows. Past four, people stop reading. Save the full spec sheet for the product page.
- A real competitor's packaging on their side. Even blurred, it's the kind of thing that gets ads reported and removed.
- Body or health claims in your column. "Helps you lose weight" vs "makes you gain it" is exactly what Meta's policies restrict. Compare what's in the product, not what it does to a body — and use only real numbers from your own label.
Questions people ask
What is an us vs them ad?
An us vs them ad puts your product side by side with the alternative people use today, in short matched columns, so the reasons to switch are visible at a glance.
Can I name a competitor in a Facebook ad?
Meta's policies don't forbid comparisons as such, but naming a rival brings trademark and legal risk that varies by country, and every claim must be accurate for that exact product. Comparing against a generic category is safer and usually just as persuasive.
How many points should the comparison have?
Three or four matched pairs. Fewer looks thin, more stops being readable at a glance, which is the whole point of the format.
Does us vs them work for premium brands?
Yes, when the differences are about craft or materials rather than price — hand-block printed vs machine printed, for example. Keep the tone calm, because knocking the alternative too hard can feel beneath a premium brand.
Keep going
- Features
Competitor ad research
What rivals keep paying for, decoded
- Ad templates
Problem–solution ad template
Name a problem people recognise, then show the fix
- Ad templates
Feature callout ad template
Your product in the middle, short labels pointing at what matters
- Ad templates
Bold claim ad template
One provable fact in giant type, on one flat colour
- Hook bank
The hook bank
Fill-in-the-blank opening lines, sorted by what they do.
- Glossary
Ad angle
An ad angle is the specific reason to buy that an ad argues — convenience, price, taste, status, a problem solved — aimed at one kind of customer. Different angles sell the same product to different people.
Every brand, person and review in these mock-ups is fictional. In your own ads, use only real reviews, real numbers and claims you can back up.
BulkAds AI is an independent product and is not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by Meta Platforms, Inc. Facebook and Instagram are trademarks of Meta Platforms, Inc.